Call Us Today:

Our carriers and their toll-free numbers

AAA Member Select
Toll Free Claim – 1-800-289-1325

Allied Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 800-282-1446

American Strategic Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 866-274-8765

American Tradidtion
Toll Free Claim - 1-866-270-8430

Bankers Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 1-800-274-7865

Bristol West
Toll Free Claim - 1-800-274-7865

Capital Preferred Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 1-888-388-2742

Chubb Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 800-252-4670

Cypress Property + Casualty
Toll Free Claim – 1-888-352-9773

Foremost Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 800-527-3907

Geovera Specialty Insurance Co
Toll Free Claim – 800-631-6478

Gulfstream Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 866-485-3005

Hagerty Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 1-800-747-5348

Heritage Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 1-855-415-7120

Homeowner Choice
Toll Free Claim – 866-324-3138

Infinity Auto Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 800-334-1661

Met Life Auto Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 800-638-5000

Toll Free Claim – 1-800-421-3535

Olympus Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 1-866-281-2242

Progressive Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 800-Progressive (1-800-776-4737 ext 483)

Toll Free Claim – 800-332-3226

Safepoint Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 866-482-5246

Scottsdale Insurance Company
Toll Free Claim – 800-423-7675 (Option 1)

Southern Fidelity
Toll Free Claim – 1-866-722-4995

Still Water Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 800-220-1351

St. Johns Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 877-748-2059

Tower Hill Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 1-800-342-3407

Travelers Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 800-252-4633

Our Location

Abney Insurance Agency

1155 Winter Garden Vineland Road, Suite 101
Winter Garden, FL 34787
Main office: 407-477-6754
Toll free: 877-615-1208

Our Providers


"Again I really appreciate all your assistance and insight more than I can say thank you. I referred two of my co-workers to your office last week along with a beyond positive recommendation."
The App is wonderful. I just downloaded it and will become more familiar with it." Silvia , customer since 1996
Just wanted to let you know how thrilled we are to be back with your company for our auto insurance needs. We signed up with you and your company almost 25 years ago when your offices were in Metro West. We left because we found a little cheaper rates while price searching but always thought we might come back one day. I wanted to let you know how helpful and professional Brandon was with my husband and myself. I'm guessing he's your son (sorry if I have that wrong) and know its always nice to get compliments where they are due. GREAT TO BE BACK. Thanks again.
"Nora J. Fussell-Smith is an absolute asset to your office. She is awesome! She always responds promptly and professionally. She has really made my job easier and given us peace of mind. If we have any questions we just "Ask Nora." Our experience thus far with Abney Insurance Agency has been great due to her."
Aaron Abney was so helpful with my husband's car claim after getting in an accident. Aaron was able to get the insurance company to pay for everything. Aaron helped me do everything!
The claim service assistance I received from Paula Abney and Monica Thilmony on a recent not at fault auto accident went beyond the call of duty. To express my sincere thanks, I presented both of the agents with a personalized coffee mug.
Joe S
I was down on my luck and was struggling to make ends meet when I thankfully talked to Paula. Not only did she help by understanding my situation, she also added a personal touch by encouraging me to push through. Abney Insurance is not only a fantastic insurance agency, but they truly care about their clients - not just their policy number. I'm so thankful to have them as my insurance agency.