Abney Insurance Agency
1155 Winter Garden Vineland Road, Suite 101
Winter Garden, FL 34787

407-477-6754
Fax: 407-877-7670

Our carriers and their toll-free numbers

AAA Member Select
Toll Free Claim – 1-800-289-1325

Allied Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 800-282-1446

American Strategic Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 866-274-8765

American Tradidtion
Toll Free Claim - 1-866-270-8430

Bankers Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 1-800-274-7865

Bristol West
Toll Free Claim - 1-800-274-7865

Capital Preferred Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 1-888-388-2742

Chubb Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 800-252-4670

Cypress Property + Casualty
Toll Free Claim – 1-888-352-9773

Foremost Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 800-527-3907

Geovera Specialty Insurance Co
Toll Free Claim – 800-631-6478

Gulfstream Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 866-485-3005

Hagerty Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 1-800-747-5348

Heritage Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 1-855-415-7120

Homeowner Choice
Toll Free Claim – 866-324-3138

Infinity Auto Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 800-334-1661

Met Life Auto Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 800-638-5000

Nationwide
Toll Free Claim – 1-800-421-3535

Olympus Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 1-866-281-2242

Progressive Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 800-Progressive (1-800-776-4737 ext 483)

Safeco
Toll Free Claim – 800-332-3226

Safepoint Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 866-482-5246

Scottsdale Insurance Company
Toll Free Claim – 800-423-7675 (Option 1)

Southern Fidelity
Toll Free Claim – 1-866-722-4995

Still Water Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 800-220-1351

St. Johns Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 877-748-2059

Tower Hill Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 1-800-342-3407

Travelers Insurance
Toll Free Claim – 800-252-4633